Krishnamurthy Subramanian, Chief Economic Adviser at the Union Finance Ministry, on Tuesday said international ratings agency Moody’s projection of 6 per cent growth rate in India is an “underestimate” as the country has been “fiscally very prudent”. He suggested the US-based firm needs to take into account India’s reforms while estimating the growth rate.
In an exclusive interview to CNBC-TV18 on the same, Subramanian said, “We have always maintained that fundamentals of the economy are strong. We pushed Moody’s to see our point of view. Banking and fiscal situation is looking better. We made our case about the economic situation in India and convinced Moody’s pointed out that this year’s budget made a clarion call for reforms. Assuaged concerns about future NPA’s from retail and MSME’s.”
“Moody’s projection of 6 per cent growth rate is an underestimate. India’s potential growth rate is 7.5 per cent. Moody’s needs to take into account India’s reforms while estimating the growth rate. India has been fiscally very prudent,” he added.
Subramanian also said that it is time international agencies take into account necessary conditions around announcement of reforms. “Private capex rates are clearly going up. Private capital investment in both services and manufacturing is picking up. India is the only country which was focused on supply side measures. Despite rising commodity prices, India’s inflation is in control. Supply side reforms will definitely spur private capex,” he said.
The reaction came after Moody’s upgraded India’s rating outlook to ‘stable’ from ‘negative’, saying a recovery is underway in Asia’s third-largest economy and growth this fiscal will surpass the pre-pandemic rate.
Moody’s Investors Service however kept India’s sovereign rating at ‘Baa3’ — which is the lowest investment grade, just a notch above junk status. The change in the rating outlook to ‘stable’ from ‘negative’, which was assigned in November 2019, reflected receding downside risks to the economy and financial system. “An economic recovery is underway with activity picking up and broadening across sectors,” Moody’s said.
Following a deep contraction of 7.3 per cent in fiscal 2020 (ended March 2021), Moody’s expects India’s real GDP to surpass 2019 levels this fiscal year (April 2021 to March 2022), rebounding to a growth rate of 9.3 per cent, followed by 7.9 per cent in the next financial year. “Downside risks to growth from subsequent coronavirus infection waves are mitigated by rising vaccination rates and more selective use of restrictions on economic activity, as seen during the second wave,” it noted.
The US-based rating firm had in 2020 lowered India’s rating from ‘Baa2’ with a ‘negative’ outlook, saying there would be challenges in policy implementation amid low growth and deteriorating fiscal position. In a statement on Tuesday, Moody’s said “the decision to change the outlook to stable reflects Moody’s view that the downside risks from negative feedback between the real economy and financial system are receding.”
Looking ahead, Moody’s expects real GDP growth to average around 6 per cent over the medium term, reflecting a rebound in activity as conditions normalise. The government announced reforms throughout the pandemic that include measures aimed at increasing the flexibility of labour laws, raising agricultural sector efficiency, expanding investment in infrastructure, incentivising manufacturing sector investment and strengthening the financial sector. “If implemented effectively, these policy actions would be credit positive and could lead to higher potential growth than expected,” Moody’s said.
However, it noted that India’s general government debt burden increased sharply from 74 per cent of GDP in 2019 to an estimated 89 per cent of 2020 GDP, significantly higher than the ‘Baa’ median of around 48 per cent. “Looking ahead, Moody’s expects the debt burden to stabilise at around 91 per cent over the medium term, as strong nominal GDP growth is balanced by a gradually shrinking, but still sizeable, primary deficit. “Combined, a higher debt burden and weaker debt affordability than before the pandemic, which Moody’s expects to persist, contribute to lower fiscal strength,” It said.
(with inputs from PTI)